Audi e-tron GT vs. Tesla Model S

Performance: A Tale of Two Powertrains

Both the Audi e-tron GT and the Tesla Model S deliver impressive performance, but their powertrain configurations and driving dynamics differ significantly.

Audi e-tron GT: Electrified Quattro

The Audi e-tron GT boasts Audi’s renowned Quattro all-wheel-drive system, driven by two electric motors – one on each axle . This setup provides exceptional traction and handling, allowing the e-tron GT to accelerate from 0 to 60 mph in a brisk 3.9 seconds in the standard model and a blistering 3.1 seconds in the RS version . A unique feature in the EV landscape, the e-tron GT features a two-speed transmission on the rear axle . This transmission allows for a balance of rapid acceleration and efficient high-speed cruising. The RS e-tron GT even offers a carbon fiber roof to reduce weight and lower the center of gravity, further enhancing performance .   

To further enhance the e-tron GT’s performance, Audi offers an optional Performance package . This package includes dynamic steering, which adjusts the steering ratio based on speed and driving conditions, and rear-wheel steering, which improves agility at low speeds and stability at high speeds. The Performance package also includes e-torque vectoring, which precisely distributes torque between the rear wheels to optimize traction and handling.   

The e-tron GT’s performance is further enhanced by its three-chamber air suspension, which was meticulously tuned on the demanding Nürburgring Nordschleife race track . This sophisticated suspension system provides a balance of comfort and sportiness, adapting to different driving conditions and driver preferences. Available all-wheel steering further enhances agility and maneuverability, especially at low speeds .   

Tesla Model S: Unbridled Acceleration

The Tesla Model S offers even more potent acceleration, particularly in the top-of-the-line Plaid trim. With three electric motors – one in the front and two in the rear – the Model S Plaid catapults from 0 to 60 mph in a mind-bending 1.99 seconds . This incredible acceleration is aided by Tesla’s “Cheetah Stance” launch control feature, which optimizes weight distribution for maximum traction . Even the standard dual-motor Model S achieves a respectable 0-60 mph time of 3.1 seconds . The Model S also boasts a higher top speed than the e-tron GT, reaching 200 mph in the Plaid trim compared to the e-tron GT’s 155.3 mph .   

Driving Experience: On the Road

While both vehicles offer impressive performance figures, the actual driving experience differs significantly. The Audi e-tron GT, with its Quattro all-wheel-drive system, two-speed transmission, and sophisticated suspension, delivers a balanced and engaging driving experience. It feels planted and confident in corners, providing a sense of connection to the road . The Tesla Model S, with its instant torque and lighter weight, offers a more raw and exhilarating acceleration. However, some reviewers find the Model S’s steering feel to be less communicative than the e-tron GT’s .   

Luxury: A Matter of Taste

Inside the cabin, both the Audi e-tron GT and the Tesla Model S offer luxurious appointments and advanced technology, but their design philosophies and material choices create distinct atmospheres.

Audi e-tron GT: Traditional Craftsmanship Meets Modern Technology

The e-tron GT’s interior exudes a sense of traditional Audi craftsmanship, with high-quality materials and meticulous attention to detail . The cabin features a driver-focused layout, with a 12.3-inch Audi virtual cockpit and a 10.1-inch MMI touch response display . A variety of interior options are available, including leather upholstery with different color choices and a leather-free package that uses recycled materials . For an even more immersive audio experience, the e-tron GT offers an available Bang & Olufsen sound system . The seats are comfortable and supportive, providing a cosseting experience for both driver and passengers. Adding to the luxurious ambiance, the e-tron GT offers an available glass roof with transparency control . This innovative feature allows drivers to adjust the amount of light entering the cabin, creating an open and airy feel while also providing shade when needed.   

Tesla Model S: Minimalist Chic and Tech-Forward

The Model S takes a more minimalist approach to interior design, with a clean and uncluttered dashboard dominated by a massive 17-inch touchscreen . This touchscreen controls virtually all vehicle functions, from climate control to entertainment. The Model S also features a yoke steering wheel, which provides an unobstructed view of the road and the instrument panel . While this design choice enhances visibility and creates a unique driver connection, it may not be to everyone’s taste. Some drivers may find the yoke steering less comfortable or intuitive than a traditional steering wheel.   

The Model S’s interior is undeniably modern and tech-forward, with features like over-the-air updates that allow for continuous improvement and the addition of new features over time . However, some may find it lacking in the tactile feedback and traditional luxury feel of the e-tron GT. The Model S also boasts a spacious cargo capacity thanks to its hatchback design . This design allows for easier loading and unloading of larger items compared to the e-tron GT’s traditional trunk.   

Range and Charging: Electrifying the Journey

Both the Audi e-tron GT and the Tesla Model S offer competitive driving ranges and fast charging capabilities, ensuring that long journeys are not hampered by range anxiety.

Audi e-tron GT: Balancing Range and Charging Speed

The Audi e-tron GT has an EPA-estimated range of 238 miles for the regular model and 232 miles for the RS model . While these figures are respectable, they fall short of the Tesla Model S’s longer range. However, the e-tron GT can charge at a rate of up to 270 kW, allowing it to replenish its battery from 5 to 80 percent in a claimed 23 minutes . The e-tron GT utilizes the CCS charging standard, which is becoming increasingly common in public charging networks .   

Tesla Model S: Leading the Range Race

The Tesla Model S boasts a significantly longer range than the e-tron GT, with the standard model achieving an EPA-estimated 405 miles and the Plaid model reaching 348 miles . This impressive range gives the Model S a clear advantage for long-distance driving. However, the Model S’s maximum charging rate of 250 kW is slightly lower than the e-tron GT’s.   

When it comes to charging infrastructure, the two vehicles take different approaches. Tesla’s extensive Supercharger network provides convenient and reliable charging options for Model S owners, with over 60,000 Superchargers placed along popular routes . However, access to this network is restricted to Tesla vehicles . The e-tron GT, on the other hand, utilizes the CCS charging standard, which is compatible with a wider range of public charging networks. While the CCS network may not be as extensive as Tesla’s Supercharger network, it offers greater flexibility and choice for e-tron GT owners.   

Features and Technology: A Digital Showcase

Both the Audi e-tron GT and the Tesla Model S are packed with advanced technology and convenience features, enhancing the driving experience and providing a glimpse into the future of automotive innovation.

Audi e-tron GT: A Blend of Comfort and Convenience

The e-tron GT offers a comprehensive suite of features, including a head-up display, a Bang & Olufsen premium sound system, and a variety of driver-assistance systems . For enhanced safety and convenience, the e-tron GT offers available driver-assistance systems such as adaptive cruise control and lane keeping assist . These features help reduce driver fatigue and enhance safety on long drives. The e-tron GT also supports Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, providing seamless smartphone integration . The e-tron GT also features matrix-design LED headlights with high-beam assist, which provide improved visibility and safety in low-light conditions .   

Tesla Model S: A Tech-Centric Approach

The Model S pushes the boundaries of in-car technology with its large touchscreen, yoke steering, and advanced Autopilot system . The Model S also features a rear-seat entertainment display with a gaming computer, providing passengers with a unique and engaging experience . For enhanced safety, the Model S includes active safety features such as Automatic Emergency Braking . To improve cabin air quality, the Model S features a HEPA filtration system and Bioweapon Defense Mode, which filters out harmful pollutants and allergens . However, the Model S lacks Apple CarPlay and Android Auto support, which may be a drawback for some users .   

Reliability and Maintenance: The Long-Term View

While both the Audi e-tron GT and the Tesla Model S are relatively new models, their respective brands have established track records in terms of reliability and maintenance.

Audi e-tron GT: Leveraging Audi’s Legacy

Audi has a long history of producing high-quality vehicles, and the e-tron GT is expected to benefit from this legacy. Audi offers a 4-year/50,000-mile warranty and an 8-year/100,000-mile battery warranty . This comprehensive warranty coverage provides peace of mind for e-tron GT owners.   

Tesla Model S: A Mixed Bag

Tesla’s reliability record has been mixed, with some models experiencing quality issues. However, Tesla has been improving its manufacturing processes and customer service in recent years. Tesla offers a 4-year/50,000-mile warranty and an 8-year/160,000-mile battery warranty . While the longer battery warranty is appealing, Tesla’s overall reliability remains a concern for some buyers.   

Pricing and Options: Value Proposition

Both the Audi e-tron GT and the Tesla Model S are premium vehicles with a price tag to match. However, their pricing and available options differ, offering different value propositions for potential buyers.

Audi e-tron GT: Premium Pricing with Customization Options

The Audi e-tron GT starts at $107,995 for the Premium Plus trim and goes up to $148,595 for the RS trim . Audi offers a variety of packages and options, allowing buyers to customize their e-tron GT to their preferences. This level of customization allows buyers to tailor the e-tron GT to their specific needs and desires, but it also means that the price can quickly escalate with added options.   

Tesla Model S: Competitive Pricing with Limited Options

The Tesla Model S starts at $81,630 for the base model and $91,630 for the Plaid trim . Tesla offers fewer customization options than Audi, but the Model S’s lower starting price makes it a more accessible option for some buyers. The limited options may be a drawback for those who desire a higher level of personalization, but it also simplifies the buying process and keeps the price more predictable.   

Conclusion: A Close Contest

The Audi e-tron GT and the Tesla Model S are both exceptional EVs that offer a compelling blend of performance, luxury, and technology. The e-tron GT excels in its refined interior, balanced handling, and fast charging capabilities. The Model S stands out with its blistering acceleration, impressive range, and tech-forward features. Ultimately, the best choice depends on individual preferences and priorities.

For buyers who prioritize a luxurious and refined driving experience, the Audi e-tron GT is a compelling choice. Its meticulously crafted interior, balanced handling, and available advanced technology create a truly premium EV experience. The Tesla Model S, on the other hand, appeals to those who seek the ultimate in performance and technology. Its record-breaking acceleration, impressive range, and innovative features like the yoke steering and over-the-air updates push the boundaries of EV technology.

While both vehicles offer strong value propositions, the Tesla Model S’s lower starting price and longer range may make it a more attractive option for budget-conscious buyers and those who prioritize long-distance driving. However, the Audi e-tron GT’s higher level of customization and Audi’s reputation for quality may appeal to those who value personalization and long-term reliability.

This comparison highlights the diverse approaches to luxury and performance in the EV market. As the EV landscape continues to evolve, we can expect to see even more exciting and innovative vehicles that cater to a wide range of preferences and needs.